The Ultimate Guide to Nantucket Hotels: Where to Stay for the Perfect Island Getaway

If you're planning a dreamy coastal escape, few places can rival the timeless charm of Nantucket. Just 30 miles off the coast of Massachusetts, this iconic island offers pristine beaches, cobblestone streets, stunning lighthouses, and a laid-back elegance that has been attracting visitors for centuries. But where you stay can make or break your experience — and when it comes to Nantucket hotels, you have a wide range of luxurious, cozy, and classic options to choose from.

In this guide, we’ll cover everything you need to know about hotels in Nantucket, from the most luxurious stays to affordable hidden gems, insider booking tips, and answers to common questions. Whether you're planning a romantic weekend, a family vacation, or a solo retreat, this is your go-to guide for finding the best hotels Nantucket has to offer.

Why Choose Nantucket?

Before we dive into the best hotels, it’s important to understand what makes Nantucket special:

• Historic Charm: Many buildings date back to the 18th and 19th centuries.
• World-Class Beaches: Over 80 miles of coastline.
• Exclusive Feel: Limited size and seasonal tourism create an upscale, peaceful vibe.
• Cultural Richness: Whaling museums, art galleries, fine dining, and boutique shopping.
• Outdoor Activities: Surfing, sailing, biking, fishing, and hiking.

Because the island is relatively small, choosing the right hotel — in the right location — is key to maximizing your Nantucket experience.

Top Luxury Nantucket Hotels

If you’re looking to splurge on a high-end experience, Nantucket offers several five-star properties that blend history, luxury, and comfort.

1. The Nantucket Hotel & Resort

Located just a short walk from downtown, this grand historic hotel offers a truly all-encompassing luxury experience. Featuring spacious suites, heated pools, a wellness spa, and on-site dining at Breeze Restaurant, it’s an ideal choice for families, couples, and weddings.
Highlights:

• Complimentary kids' club
• Ferry pick-up service
• Seasonal events and activities

2. White Elephant Hotel

The White Elephant is a Nantucket icon, known for its waterfront location and timeless New England style. This luxury hotel offers rooms, suites, garden cottages, and even in-town lofts for extended stays.
Highlights:

• Waterfront dining at Brant Point Grill
• Full-service spa
• Stunning harbor views

3. Greydon House

For those who want boutique luxury blended with historic charm, Greydon House is a top contender. This intimate hotel, set within a restored 1850s home, is steps from Nantucket’s lively downtown shops and restaurants.
Highlights:

• Award-winning interiors
• Michelin-recognized restaurant
• Walking distance to Brant Point and the ferry

Best Mid-Range and Affordable Hotels in Nantucket

Believe it or not, it’s possible to find stylish, affordable places to stay on the island, especially if you book early or visit outside of peak summer season.

1. Hotel Pippa

Trendy and full of character, Hotel Pippa offers a curated, contemporary experience at more affordable rates compared to the large resorts. Its central location makes it easy to explore Nantucket’s downtown by foot.
Highlights:

• Complimentary breakfast
• Artistic, Instagrammable interiors
• Adults-only, perfect for couples

2. The Beachside on Nantucket

Family-friendly and budget-conscious, The Beachside is located near Jetties Beach and the Brant Point area. With outdoor pools, free parking, and pet-friendly rooms, it's a great value.
Highlights:

• Outdoor pool
• Walkable to the beach
• Ideal for families and groups

3. The Jared Coffin House

This historic inn offers a taste of Nantucket’s whaling-era grandeur at surprisingly reasonable rates. With modern upgrades alongside period architecture, it’s a charming step back in time.
Highlights:

• Downtown location
• Historic guest rooms
• On-site dining and lounge

Boutique and Unique Stays

If you want a more personal, boutique experience, Nantucket delivers with charming inns and one-of-a-kind hotels.

1. 21 Broad

A stylish boutique hotel located right downtown, 21 Broad offers colorful, modern interiors in a restored Victorian house. Think urban chic meets beachy charm.
Highlights:

• Complimentary breakfast
• Outdoor courtyard with fire pit
• Wellness amenities like vitamin C showers

2. Union Street Inn

A luxury bed-and-breakfast-style inn perfect for romantic getaways. Rated one of the top small hotels in the U.S., Union Street Inn offers a true Nantucket experience with personalized service.
Highlights:

• Gourmet breakfast included
• Elegant, individually designed rooms
• Close to ferries and downtown attractions

When to Book Your Nantucket Hotel

Nantucket is a seasonal destination, so timing matters a lot for availability and price.
Here’s a general guide:

Season	Hotel Rates	Best For
Mid-June to Labor Day	Highest	Beaches, lively events
Late April to Early June	Moderate	Spring blooms, fewer crowds
September to October	Moderate	Beautiful fall weather, discounted rates
November to March	Lowest	Quiet getaways, Christmas Stroll event

 

Pro Tip: Book at least 6–9 months in advance for summer stays, especially if you're eyeing the top-rated Nantucket hotels.

Neighborhoods to Consider

Choosing where to stay on Nantucket is just as important as choosing your hotel. Each area offers a slightly different vibe:

• Downtown Nantucket: Best for those who want to walk everywhere, shop, dine, and explore history.
• Brant Point: Close to beaches and the harbor; quieter and family-friendly.
• Siasconset ("Sconset"): Charming village atmosphere, further from the bustle.
• Madaket: Perfect for sunset lovers and laid-back beach days.
• Surfside: Great for beach lovers wanting a less crowded experience.

Tips for Booking Hotels in Nantucket

1. Book Early: Top hotels can sell out 6–12 months ahead, especially for major holidays.
2. Stay Midweek: Weekend rates can be significantly higher.
3. Consider Shoulder Seasons: May, June, September, and October offer beautiful weather with lower prices and thinner crowds.
4. Look for Packages: Some hotels offer ferry packages, bike rentals, spa credits, and dining discounts.
5. Know the Transport Options: Many hotels offer complimentary shuttle services to/from the ferry terminals and beaches.

FAQs About Nantucket Hotels

1. Is it better to stay in downtown Nantucket or near the beach? It depends! Downtown hotels offer access to shops, restaurants, and history, while beachside stays provide a more relaxed, seaside feel. Many travelers enjoy a combination — staying downtown but biking to beaches.
2. How much does it cost to stay at a Nantucket hotel? In peak season, average nightly rates range from $300–$2,000+ depending on the property. Off-season rates can drop as low as $150–$400 per night.
3. Are there pet-friendly hotels in Nantucket? Yes! Some great options include The Nantucket Hotel & Resort and The Beachside on Nantucket. Always call ahead to confirm pet policies.
4. Are Nantucket hotels open year-round? Some luxury and boutique hotels close for the winter (November–March), but many remain open for holiday events like the famous Nantucket Christmas Stroll.

Final Thoughts: Finding Your Perfect Nantucket Hotel

Nantucket offers a magical blend of old-world charm, scenic beauty, and refined relaxation — and where you stay will set the tone for your entire trip.
Whether you're looking for five-star luxury, a cozy boutique inn, or an affordable island escape, the best Nantucket hotels combine classic New England hospitality with modern comfort.

Book early, choose your ideal location, and prepare for an unforgettable stay in one of America's most beloved island destinations.

Happy travels — and see you on Nantucket!